XR can make shipping safer, but the technology is both costly and demanding
Fire, evacuation and other critical situations are difficult, expensive and sometimes dangerous to practise at sea. Virtual training could make it possible to train more frequently and without risk. However, according to a new pre-study from Lighthouse and the Swedish Transport Administration, it is essential that XR technology is built on a solid pedagogical foundation.
As early as 2019, Lighthouse explored the possibilities of using VR for safety training in shipping. The feasibility study VR at Sea identified considerable potential. In virtual environments, crews could practise scenarios such as fires and evacuations without risk, repeating difficult procedures over and over again.
At the same time, there were unanswered questions. How effective is VR as a training tool? Could the technology create a false sense of security? And does a more engaging experience actually lead to better learning?
“I read the study and thought it would be interesting to take it further and develop more concrete training scenarios using today’s technology,” says Staffan Bram, a researcher at RISE who led the feasibility study XR for Maritime Safety Training, carried out within the Swedish Transport Administration’s Sustainable Shipping programme, which is managed by Lighthouse.
A great deal has, of course, happened with the technology over the past seven years. Today, XR, Extended Reality, is used as an umbrella term for several technologies that combine physical and digital environments. In Virtual Reality (VR), the physical surroundings are shut out entirely and the user is immersed in a digital environment. Augmented Reality (AR), by contrast, overlays digital information onto the real world, while Mixed Reality (MR) goes one step further by allowing virtual objects to interact with the physical environment.
According to the study, which was conducted together with shipping companies and XR developers, XR has significant potential to become a valuable complement to traditional safety training.
For Staffan Bram, one of its main advantages is the opportunity to overcome some of the limitations of today’s exercises.
“We often get stuck in old routines, using the same scenarios and methods. With XR, you can adjust different parameters, vary the conditions and create a greater sense of realism. For example, crew members can practise how to act under stress or carry out a repair in a high-pressure situation. This was highlighted as particularly important during the project workshops. At the same time, people can practise hazardous tasks with a high degree of realism without exposing anyone to actual risk. You can introduce loud noises, panicking people, smoke or failed lighting. That provides an opportunity to train mental preparedness,” says Staffan Bram.
But just as in 2019, one crucial question remains: does it actually improve learning?
Not automatically, Staffan Bram stresses.
“The technology itself does not make anyone learn better. It is entirely about how you use it. There has to be a solid pedagogical foundation, with clear learning objectives, appropriately designed content and feedback.”
According to the report, XR exercises must therefore be based on a pedagogical framework. But how do you create such a framework in practice, and who has the expertise to do it?
“That is a good question. Ultimately, much of the responsibility for running and developing safety training lies with the officers on board. Larger shipping companies may receive support from their shore-based organisations, but that is not always the case. At the same time, it is asking a great deal of officers to also have in-depth pedagogical expertise. Training providers have that competence, but when it comes to everyday training, much of the responsibility still falls on the crew and officers themselves. Better guidance and support are needed than what is available today.”
There are also practical obstacles. XR training is expensive to develop, and considerable technical expertise is required to build and maintain realistic virtual environments and training scenarios.
“It can be difficult to make sufficient use of the technology to justify the investment. You need to be able to train across a sufficiently wide range of scenarios. That is why we concluded that, at least initially, the most effective solution would be some form of subscription service in which a provider offers more standardised training scenarios. These could then be supplemented with scenarios tailored to a specific shipping company or vessel,” says Staffan Bram.
The report XR for Maritime Safety Training was written by Staffan Bram, RISE, and Fredrick Ekman, Chalmers.
-
Nya kriterier för sjöegenskaper sätter besättningen i centrum -
Fossilberoendet kan ersättas av ett importberoende -
XR kan göra sjöfarten säkrare, men tekniken är både dyr och krävande -
Kärnkraft för dyrt för sjöfarten -
Se Hållbar sjöfarts uppsamlingsheat -
Ny portal gör det enklare att välja sjöfart -
Lighthouse omvärldsanalys 2026 – sjöfarten påverkas av en allt osäkrare värld -
9,5 meter hög mast säkrar vätgasdrift -
Svårt att jämföra sjöfartens klimatmodeller -
Se seminariet Could nuclear power become part of the future of Swedish shipping?